-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 3.4k
Enhance Streamlit with modern components and variables #1663
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Conversation
- Resolved merge conflicts in README.md by combining the best of both versions - Maintained Streamlit UI documentation with enhanced features - Removed conflicting patternstudio.py file - Updated web interface documentation to reflect both GUI and Streamlit options - Added clipboard support documentation for cross-platform compatibility - Preserved contributing guidelines from the original PR
- Restore comprehensive 3,100+ line streamlit.py with modern components - Add STREAMLIT_ENHANCEMENTS.md documentation - Includes st.pills(), st.segmented_control(), st.feedback(), st.toast(), st.dialog() - Enhanced pattern management, analytics, and user experience - Cross-platform clipboard support and modern styling
✨ NEW FEATURE: Pattern Variables Support 🔧 Core Implementation: - detect_pattern_variables() - Regex-based {{variable}} detection - render_pattern_variables_ui() - Dynamic input field generation - validate_pattern_variables() - Required variable validation - substitute_pattern_variables() - Variable substitution utility 🎯 UI Enhancements: - Variable indicators in pattern selection (🔧 icon + count) - Smart placeholders based on variable names (author, topic, etc.) - Tabbed interface for multiple patterns with variables - Real-time validation with execution button state management - Clear error messages for missing required variables ⚙️ Execution Integration: - Enhanced execute_patterns_enhanced() with variable support - Updated execute_pattern_chain() for chain mode variables - Passes variables to fabric CLI using --variable flags - Works seamlessly with both single and chain execution modes 📚 Documentation: - Updated STREAMLIT_ENHANCEMENTS.md with comprehensive examples - Added technical implementation details - Included usage examples and future enhancement plans This addresses ksylvan's feedback about adding support for patterns that require variables, making the Streamlit UI fully compatible with parameterized patterns like write_essay.
📋 Action Plan Updates: - Marked all completed phases as done - Updated checklist status for implemented features - Documented successful resolution of all ksylvan feedback 🎯 Completion Summary: - Comprehensive overview of all resolved issues - Technical implementation details for pattern variables - Validation checklist confirming all requirements met - Next steps for PR finalization All of ksylvan's feedback has been addressed: ✅ README.md restored ✅ Enhanced Streamlit UI restored and improved ✅ Branch synced with upstream ✅ Pattern variables support fully implemented ✅ Documentation updated with examples
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Pull Request Overview
This PR significantly enhances the Fabric Streamlit UI with modern components and comprehensive pattern variables support. The key focus is addressing reviewer feedback while adding the highly requested ability to execute patterns that require variables. The PR restores the enhanced UI that was accidentally removed and syncs with the latest upstream changes.
- Comprehensive pattern variables system with automatic detection and dynamic UI generation
- Modern Streamlit 2024 components with graceful fallbacks for older versions
- Enhanced pattern execution with real-time validation and visual feedback
Reviewed Changes
Copilot reviewed 5 out of 5 changed files in this pull request and generated 4 comments.
Show a summary per file
File | Description |
---|---|
scripts/python_ui/streamlit.py | Complete UI overhaul with pattern variables support, modern components, and enhanced execution capabilities |
scripts/python_ui/STREAMLIT_ENHANCEMENTS.md | Comprehensive documentation of new features and technical implementation |
README.md | Updated web interface documentation to clarify different UI options |
PR_1655_COMPLETION_SUMMARY.md | Detailed summary of all issues resolved and features implemented |
PR_1655_ACTION_PLAN.md | Technical action plan and validation checklist for the PR |
Comments suppressed due to low confidence (2)
scripts/python_ui/streamlit.py:1426
- [nitpick] The function name
execute_patterns_enhanced
suggests it's a temporary or alternative version. Consider renaming to something more descriptive likeexecute_patterns_with_variables
or updating the original function
def execute_patterns_enhanced(
scripts/python_ui/streamlit.py:2904
- [nitpick] The pattern of storing outputs in session state and then immediately clearing them suggests a design issue. Consider refactoring to avoid temporary state variables
# Display output from the last run and then clear it
@sosacrazy126 Good stuff. Have you addressed the issues pointed out by Copilot? |
@ksylvan no i will do that now |
Co-authored-by: Copilot <[email protected]>
Co-authored-by: Copilot <[email protected]>
Co-authored-by: Copilot <[email protected]>
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
I'll do a very focused review of the Streamlit UI code changes (and I will check out your branch and run it locally too for a final verification).
Thank you for the contribution!
Was this generated by Opencode or Claude Code?
- Reverted README.md to upstream version with minimal enhancement - Added single line about pattern variables support in Streamlit UI section - Removed PR_1655_ACTION_PLAN.md and PR_1655_COMPLETION_SUMMARY.md files - Keeping changes focused and top-level directory clean as requested Addresses ksylvan's feedback: - README changes are now minimal and focused - Documentation files removed from top-level directory - Only essential enhancement mentioned in appropriate section
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Okay, @sosacrazy126 - I noticed that my question about whether this code was generated by AI hasn't been addressed yet.
Which tool and model did you use?
I'm not saying that using AI tooling is bad, not at all, but we need to be careful about what the AI produces, and at times, we need to keep iterating on it over and over and over again till it achieves the desired level of code quality.
I want to make sure that you and I together can collaborate to create really clean and functional high-quality code.
While the functionality of the Streamlit UI appears comprehensive, there are several areas that need attention, particularly around error handling, code organization, and potential security concerns.
What I'd like to see is for you to:
-
Refactor the massive main() function into smaller, focused functions for better maintainability (possibly even breaking it into modules of related functions—this would also help with being able to thoroughly review the code and also do a proper security audit).
-
Add proper error handling for all new UI components and external dependencies
Basically, the Streamlit UI code needs a complete refactoring/rewrite.
@ksylvan, sorry for the delay in replying! Yep — I used Claude Code for both the original streamlit.py and the enhanced version 😄. I also pulled in the latest docs using ref-tools-mcp. sonnet 4 and a mix of mcp tools |
To be honest with you, the Claude-generated code in this case is not that good, unfortunately. Please collaborate with it more and implement my suggested refactoring. The goal is to come up with a much cleaner, less verbose, more python-idiomatic version of the Streamlit UI that also implements your desired enhancements. |
can you elaborate on what you mean |
Read my comments above fully. To be completely blunt: Your Claude-generated code is a nightmare to navigate and maintain. I'll repeat what I wrote above: While the functionality of the Streamlit UI appears comprehensive, there are several areas that need attention, particularly around error handling, code organization, and potential security concerns. What I'd like to see is for you to: Refactor the massive main() function into smaller, focused functions for better maintainability (possibly even breaking it into modules of related functions—this would also help with being able to thoroughly review the code and also do a proper security audit). Add proper error handling for all new UI components and external dependencies Basically, the Streamlit UI code needs a complete refactoring/rewrite. For example, among many approaches to breaking the massive main() function into components would be something like this (you'll have to extend this and think from what I am saying below): def main():
"""Main function to run the Streamlit app."""
logger.info("Starting Fabric Pattern Studio")
initialize_app()
try:
render_header()
setup_sidebar()
view = get_current_view()
if view == "Run Patterns":
render_pattern_execution_view()
elif view == "Pattern Management":
render_pattern_management_view()
else:
render_analysis_dashboard_view()
except Exception as e:
handle_application_error(e)
def initialize_app():
"""Initialize application configuration and state."""
st.set_page_config(
page_title="Fabric Pattern Studio",
page_icon="🎭",
layout="wide",
initial_sidebar_state="expanded",
)
apply_custom_styling()
initialize_session_state()
def render_pattern_execution_view():
"""Render the main pattern execution interface."""
# Implementation here
pass The main function is over 400 lines long and handles multiple responsibilities, including UI rendering, state management, and business logic. Breaking it into focused functions improves readability, testability, and maintainability. Each function should have a single responsibility and be easier to debug and modify. Similarly, instead of one file, you should reorganize the Streamlit UI into a proper Pythonic set of modules, separating the functions that take care of similar/related things into one file. |
Enhance Streamlit with modern components and variables
What this Pull Request (PR) does
This PR significantly enhances the Fabric Streamlit UI with modern
components and adds comprehensive pattern variables support. Key
improvements include:
🔧 Pattern Variables Support (NEW)
count)
🎨 Modern UI Enhancements
st.segmented_control()
,st.feedback()
,st.toast()
,st.dialog()
,st.status()
)* Enhanced pattern selection with tags and filtering
* Interactive feedback system with thumbs up/down rating
* Advanced analytics and execution statistics
* Cross-platform clipboard support (macOS, Windows, Linux)
* Modern styling with gradients and animations
* Welcome screen for new users
⚙️ Technical Improvements
Related issues
This PR addresses feedback from @ksylvan in the original review
comments: